Perceptions of the
Cosmos
INTD 321
Course Description
In the past four
hundred years, peoples' understanding of the physical universe has undergone
significant changes. Most striking have been those which occurred during the
first few decades of the Twentieth Century. Unfortunately, the nature of these
changes and their implications are not generally understood. Most people even
today still use pre-Newtonian concepts (those originating with Aristotle and
used by nearly everyone prior to the latter 1600's) when they think about the
behavior of the physical world. Since we now live in an age when the application
of the newly developed knowledge is changing significantly our patterns of
living, it seems important to provide an opportunity for students to examine
carefully the changes in basic knowledge which have occurred.
An introductory
course in physics normally presents physics theory as practiced by a physicist.
The student is expected to be able to work numerous problems but is not
confronted with the world view from which the theory comes. In an introductory
philosophy course which deals with science, questions of human meaning and the
significance of science together with examinations of the sense in which science
expresses the way the world "really is" may be presented. Students are
not asked to work with the details of physical theory which are the substance of
science.
In this ID course
which interrelates physics and philosophy, both detail of physical theory and
the world view from which they arise and which they imply will be presented.
Through the course, the classical perspective of Galileo and Newton (which was a
revolutionary and hard-fought change from the Aristotelian world view that was
the accepted Atruth@ for nearly 2,000 years) will be contrasted with the modern
perspective of Einstein and Heisenberg. The intent is not to dwell on the
technical details (important as they are), but to bring out some of the large
general implications.
The time line below
shows the periods of time during which the three major views of the structure
and behavior of the universe were held together with the key people involved in
the development of those views.
Time line
(Empedocles Galileo
Michelson & Morley
490-430 BC)
1564-1642 1887
300 BC 1642 1900
Aristotle Newton
Planck Einstein Heisenberg-1925
384-322 BC 1642-1727
1900 1905&1916 Schrödinger-1926
Aristotelian World
View Newtonian World View Contemporary World View
Aristotelian Physics
Newtonian Physics Modern Physics
Classical Physics
Required text books:
Physics: Concepts
and Connections,
Second Edition (1999) by Art Hobson
The Dancing Wu Li
Masters
by Gary Zukav
Hand-out reading
material from text books no longer in print:
The Philosophical
Impact of Contemporary Physics
by Mili… „apek
Invitation to
Physics
by Ken Greider
Physics: The Fabric
of Reality
by S. K. Kim
|
ID
321 Course Schedule and Assignments: Fall 3-week Term, 1998 |
|
Session |
Topic |
Assignment |
|
Mon.
Nov. 30 (a.m.) |
Course
outline and course objectives |
|
|
p.m. |
Aristotelian
world view |
Hobson,
pp. 2-15
Greider
handout, pp. 1-top of 16.
Spielberg
handout, pp. 26-32. |
|
Tue.
Dec. 1 (a.m.) |
The
birth of new insights |
Hobson,
pp. 15-31
Greider
handout, Chapter 3.
Spielberg
handout, pp. 32-50. |
|
p.m. |
Classical
concepts of space |
„apek
handout, pp. 15-31 (beginning with AThe Homogeneity of Space and its
Consequences@). |
|
Wed.
Dec. 2 (a.m.) |
Classical
concepts of time |
„apek
handout, pp. 35-51. |
|
p.m. |
Classical
concepts of matter |
„apek
handout, pp. 54-65. |
|
Thu.
Dec. 3 (a.m.) |
Classical
concepts of motion (speed, velocity and acceleration) |
Hobson,
pp. 64-80 & 109-118
March
handout, pp. 5-21.
Kim
handout, pp. 1-7.
Handout
on Kinematics and Dynamics, Section I. |
|
p.m. |
Classical
concepts of motion (Newton's Laws of Motion, momentum, energy) |
Hobson,
pp. 86-104
March
handout, pp. 22-26 and 33-41.
Handout
on Kinematics and Dynamics, Section II. |
|
Fri.
Dec. 4 (a.m.) |
Conservation
of momentum and conservation of energy principles |
Hobson,
pp.138-147
Handout
on Kinematics and Dynamics, Section II.
March
handout, pp. bottom 26-32. |
|
p.m. |
Implications
of the corpuscular-kinetic view of the universe |
„apek
handout pp.121-middle of 128 (more if you wish).
„apek
handout, pp. 135-140 (skip p. 137). |
|
Mon.
Dec. 7 (a.m.) |
Review
for first test |
„apek
handout, pp. 3-6
„apek
handout, pp. 79-89 (Main Features).
Review
Sheets for the Aristotelian World View and the Corpuscular Kinetic View of
the Universe. |
|
p.m. |
First
test (Aristotelian world view and classical concepts of space, time,
matter, and motion) |
Review
Sheet for the Aristotelian World View and Corpuscular Kinetic View of the
Universe. |
|
Tue.
Dec. 8 (a.m.) |
Classical
relative motion, the Michelson-Morley Experiment and Einstein's postulates
for the Special Theory of Relativity |
Hobson,
pp. 250-261.
„apek
handout, pp. xi-xvii (Intro.).
„apek
handout, pp. 143-middle of 147 and bottom of 151-middle of 152
(Kim
handout, pp. 15-27, Chap. 3 & 4 optional.) |
|
p.m. |
Einstein's
Special Theory of Relativity; space and time considerations |
Hobson,
pp. 262- 269 & 274-276.
Zukav,
pp. 117-128 & 134-150.
„apek
handout, pp. 152-156. |
|
Wed.
Dec. 9 (a.m.) |
Einstein's
Special Theory of Relativity; relative motion, mass and energy
considerations |
Hobson,
pp. 277-287.
Zukav,
pp. 154-159. |
|
p.m. |
Einstein's
General Theory of Relativity |
Hobson,
pp. 287-299.
Zukav,
pp. 160-187. |
|
Thu.
Dec. 10 (a.m.) |
Implications
of Einstein's Theory of Relativity for space, time, matter and motion |
„apek
handout, pp. 158-161, 164-170, 172-mid 179, & bottom 180-top 181. |
|
p.m. |
Implications
of Einstein's Theory of Relativity for space, time, matter and motion |
„apek
handout, pp. 188-193, 199-201, 205-206, & last paragraph 212.
„apek
handout, pp. 214-219, 223-225, & 230-232. |
|
Fri.
Dec. 11 (a.m.) |
Review
for second test |
Review
Sheet for Contemporary Concepts of Space and Time. |
|
p.m. |
Second
test (contemporary concepts of space and time--Einstein's Theory of
Relativity) |
Review
Sheet for Contemporary Concepts of Space and Time. |
|
Mon.
Dec. 14 (a.m.) |
Wave-particle
duality for light:
a)
Planck and Black Body radiation
b)
Einstein and the Photoelectric Effect
c)
Compton Scattering |
Kim
handout, pp. 181-189.
Zukav,
pp. 45-mid 62 and mid 93-bottom 95.
|
|
p.m. |
Nuclear
atom:
a)
Rutherford scattering
b)
Bohr model of the hydrogen atom |
Kim
handout, pp. 191-202.
|
|
Tue.
Dec. 15 (a.m.) |
Wave
nature of the electron
Single-slit/double
slit experiment
Heisenberg
Uncertainty Principle |
Kim
handout, pp. 215-226.
Hobson,
pp. 339-347.
Zukav,
pp. mid 62-66; bottom 95-lower 99 and 111-114. |
|
p.m. |
Quantum
Mechanics: Schrödinger equation and particle in a box |
Kim
handout, pp. 229-mid 236.
Hobson,
pp. bottom 347-352. |
|
Wed.
Dec. 16. (a.m.) |
Quantum
Mechanical description of the hydrogen atom and other atoms
Pauli
Exclusion Principle |
Kim
handout, pp. 208-212 and 236-238.
Hobson,
pp. 356-365.
Zukav,
pp. lower 99-110. |
|
p.m. |
Copenhagen
interpretation of quantum theory |
Zukav,
pp. 67-mid 93. |
|
Thu.
Dec. 17 (a.m.) |
Nuclear
Structure and behavior |
Hobson,
pp. 390-399 and 472-482. |
|
p.m. |
Elementary
particle summary |
Hobson,
pp. bottom 482-495. |
|
Fri.
Dec. 18 (a.m.) |
What
it all means |
Hobson,
pp. bottom 378-382.
„apek
handout, pp. 252-260; 262-270; last paragraph 275; lower 277-mid 278; top
285-287; mid 293-top 295; mid 307-mid 311. |
|
p.m. |
Review
for final exam |
Review
Sheet for Contemporary Concepts of Matter, etc. |
|
Sat.
Dec. 19,
9:00-11:00
a.m. |
Final
exam (emphasis on contemporary concepts of matter and interaction--Quantum
Mechanics and its implications--but also comprehensive) |
Review
Sheet for Contemporary Concepts of Matter, etc. and also the previous
review sheets. |
INTD
321 ATTENDANCE EXPECTATION AND POLICY
The
expectation is that you will attend every class session. There is no
specific grade penalty for up to three class sessions missed. However, if
you are absent for more than three class sessions (about 11% of the course),
your grade will be reduced by one letter grade from that earned without the
absences. Even if you are below the maximum for grade penalty, your
grade in all probability will be affected by missed classes.
First
and foremost, material and emphases are brought into the class sessions which
are not in the reading assignments. The tests are worked up on the basis of what
is presented in class. When an emphasis is given in class, it is an indication
of where your study emphasis should be. The added material brought into the
class session may appear on a test. If you have missed that in class, you
probably will do poorly on that section of the test.
Secondly,
in the case of a person who has missed two or three classes, there is a subtle
effect which is difficult to avoid. Lack of attendance is an indication to the
professor that you are not very interested in getting a lot out of the course
and so not interested in getting a very good grade in the course. That is a
subjective factor which shows up when the final grade is assigned. In any
borderline situation, the tendency is to assign the lower grade to one who has a
poor attendance record and the higher grade in the other case.
GRADING
SCHEME
Input
Weighting
Factor
First
Test 1
Second
Test 1